Ti West doesn’t really get A Christmas Carol . I think he understands the atmosphere to an extent of its scarier moments -and manifesting his own variations on them appears to be a primary reason he chose to make his own version. And I think he even comprehends on a surface level the appeal in the power of the story’s theme of redemption. But he doesn’t get the spirit of it -an important thing given it is after all a story about spirits. Early into the third chapter of the book, the Ghost of Christmas Present whisks Scrooge away to Christmas morning and a thriving elaborate display of London Christmas cheer. Dickens goes at length into emphasizing it and the kind of magical effect it has on even one so cynical as Scrooge. That scene does not take place in the film, which makes the unusual choice of setting that entire chapter -the most bright and buoyant of the whole story- at night. Further, as someone who has seen dozens of adaptations over the years, this may well be the first that ...
Criticism, Essays, and Ramblings from Another Online Film Critic. Support me on Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/JordanBosch, follow me on BlueSky at https://bsky.app/profile/jordanbosch.bsky.social and jbosch on Letterboxd