Skip to main content

Buried With a Stake of Holly Through his Heart

Ti West doesn’t really get A Christmas Carol. I think he understands the atmosphere to an extent of its scarier moments -and manifesting his own variations on them appears to be a primary reason he chose to make his own version. And I think he even comprehends on a surface level the appeal in the power of the story’s theme of redemption. But he doesn’t get the spirit of it -an important thing given it is after all a story about spirits.
Early into the third chapter of the book, the Ghost of Christmas Present whisks Scrooge away to Christmas morning and a thriving elaborate display of London Christmas cheer. Dickens goes at length into emphasizing it and the kind of magical effect it has on even one so cynical as Scrooge. That scene does not take place in the film, which makes the unusual choice of setting that entire chapter -the most bright and buoyant of the whole story- at night. Further, as someone who has seen dozens of adaptations over the years, this may well be the first that dares to cut the Crachit Christmas Dinner from the narrative, save for a minute morsel just enough to give Tiny Tim his famous line. The Crachit Christmas is more or less the centrepiece of A Christmas Carol -arguably the heart of Scrooge’s transformation. But that doesn’t matter so much to West, not when there’s room to have a horde of ghosts chase and trap Scrooge in a pub.
West wastes no time in accentuating where he can and as he sees fit the horror tenets of Ebenezer at the expense of its story’s virtues. On the surface though the narrative plays out much as you’d be familiar with: London miser Ebenezer Scrooge on the seventh Christmas Eve anniversary of the death of his partner is haunted by three spirits offering windows into the past, present, and future in pursuit of reforming his icy heart.
Johnny Depp plays Scrooge in this version, playing the part very consciously in the manner of one trying to manifest a career revival and as such his fellow actors, with a couple minor exceptions, get very little opportunity to showcase themselves. Rupert Grint is a rather dull Bob Crachit while Sam Claflin is a meagre nephew Fred (with Daisy Ridley utterly pointless as his wife). They seem completely lost in their scenes with Depp whose own performance can charitably be described as inconsistent. Clearly, he takes seriously on some level what everyone deems this movie to represent for him -and endeavours where he can to play Scrooge with a level of depth and pathos. But either by his own compulsion or the direction of West, his characteristic schtick comes into it as well and saps what credibility he might otherwise be aiming for. Approximately half of his screen-time is spent mugging meanness or fear, and occasionally he engages in a bit of slapstick, such as throwing a saucepan through Marley’s Ghost. Moments that are reminiscent of the weakest beats of Jim Carrey’s turn as the character. The character is also harmed by the reprisal of Depp’s overzealous (though withered) Sweeney Todd accent and a meagre make-up job.
Marley’s Ghost is played by Ian McKellen, and the movie actually opens on the prelude of him being alive years before the story formally begins. Placing him in proximity to Depp is a bad choice, only highlighting how much better McKellen would be in that role. As Marley he is characteristically very competent, and happens to be the benefactor of some of the effects that West does quite well, such as the ghostly chain-rattling and the loose jaw. However, both of these are also undercut by goofy devices in the camera’s focus on Scrooge -a crash-zoom that kills a genuinely inspired and creepy visual related to Marley’s chains for example. I regret my initial appreciation for seeing the wandering spirits too -an element often left out of adaptations- for how enthusiastically West exploits them as a cheap scare device totally out of keeping with their symbolic significance in the book.
The spirits themselves have likewise largely been reinterpreted as horror creatures -Andrea Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past with her pale features, blank eyes, wiry hair and dismal voice is an emotionless, hollowed-out husk. Tramell Tillman, an otherwise inspired choice for the Ghost of Christmas Present, has neither the size nor the buoyant disposition of his character -West almost focusing entirely on his rage and impatience with Scrooge, and a grim and sickly nature. His whole section of the story takes place on the night of Christmas Eve rather than Christmas Day -a fundamental change that removes much of the ebullient power of the vision. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is rendered modestly well -though even this figure is ultimately reworked in a manner that is rather banal and a touch embarrassing in its bluntness. West messes around with the final sequence, trying to appear smart, but only making it awkward and noticeably anticlimactic. Scrooge determining his own fate ahead of time isn’t subversive (his denial is a key character trait through this chapter) it just undercuts the drama.
No version of A Christmas Carol must stick religiously to its text -indeed some of the best versions, such as the 1951 and 1984 films make several particular changes and even a few additions. West adds material too and not all of it is bad -for example his slight expansion of the role of Belle (Ellie Bamber), love interest of the young Scrooge (Arthur Conti) and their relationship is perfectly fine. Though the way their break-up is handled is underwhelming, punctuated by a hilarious origin of Scrooge’s most famous catchphrase. More substantial, even for its short exposure, are the insinuations that part of Scrooge’s hatred of the poor stems from a beggar having killed his beloved boss Fezziwig (Ian Midlane) and that the charitable gentlemen he rebuffs at the start of the story are disingenuous in their work. Such choices act as a seemingly reasonable explanation for Scrooge's callousness -a conceit that is inherently anti-Dickens and which this movie flirts with entirely too much. Certainly, there is some disconnect with the story's social themes, exacerbated by those critical sequences that are muted or missing. The accountability Scrooge must take is minimal -as in the book his words are quoted back to him, but they don't seem to register on him beyond as mere callback. The vicarious relationship he forms to Tiny Tim is nonexistent, it only barely exists with Fred, and his redemption is framed as more him confronting his personal demons than actually reckoning with his behaviour and attitude and the very real effects of his actions on others.
And all throughout the spirit of Christmas is conspicuously absent. There is barely a glimmer of Christmas imagery through the film, too much of it set at night and in drab, colourless settings as is the fictitious stereotype of Victorian England. It is the most pronounced visual ramification of West's accentuation of horror elements and it robs the story of its hopeful aesthetic resonance, as well as a good deal of rich iconography. Important beats on Christmas virtues of kindness and generosity -out of which Dickens' whole thesis arises- are underplayed. Themes of this nature made as direct appeals to the audience in the dialogue of Marley's Ghost, the Spirits, the very manifestations of Ignorance and Want are tempered for the sake of a grisly special effect (in one case even a jump scare).
There is one moment where West appears to get it, or at the very least acquiesces to a tonal obligation -when the film pauses for Scrooge to witness an older Belle singing "Silent Night" while dispensing food in a debtor's prison that is carried across scenes (including with Bob Crachit and Fred) and even time -touching a little more into Scrooge's past. It expresses a unifying warmth of Christmas goodness and hope not found anywhere else in the movie. It's lovely and it is all too short-lived. Whatever spirit imbued that scene in West, departed shortly thereafter, allowing for an awkward spot of beauty in an otherwise unremarkable film. Ebenezer is not the worst Christmas Carol movie, but it may be perhaps the most lifeless. That is almost by design in the choices West makes, and even a great performance from Depp wouldn't have made a particular difference. It resembles the story enough to be a convincing shade -a Marley's Ghost of an adaptation if you will- yet there is little hint of Dickens's magnanimous convictions; no heart or soul to be found there.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Strange History of the American Spoof Movie

Parody movies have been around for a lot longer than we tend to think of them. Even from the earliest days of Hollywood there were movies meant to satirize a particular subject or genre. In the silent era, Buster Keaton was responsible for a few. And in the early sound era, almost as soon as the monster pictures took off did you see comic versions of them -Abbott and Costello hosting a few. But parody movies tended to be subtle for most of cinema history, or parody came in conjunction with another goal of the comedy. It really wasn’t until the 1980s and 90s that it took off and became popularly understood. And there is perhaps a line to be drawn to the counterculture comedy explosion that began in the 1970s through avenues like  Saturday Night Live , which frequently parodied from even its earliest years popular movies and cultural properties of the time. But that is still a way’s back. To my generation though, ‘parody movie’ is perhaps a less known term than the more blunt ‘s...

Notes on the Title Cards of The Lord of the Rings

It might be sacrilege for one who both considers The Lord of the Rings  trilogy to be one of the greatest triumphs of cinema and has been an avid lover of the films since adolescence, to declare that the original theatrical cuts of the films are better than the much beloved extended editions. Easily it’s my most controversial opinion regarding these movies. Don’t get me wrong, I do like the extended editions quite a lot, especially as someone who just enjoys spending time in that universe. They flesh it out more, add extra flavour, and in increasing the length by about an hour really emphasize the epic quality of these films. But I find that the original cuts are generally more cleanly paced, more seamlessly edited, and much more accessible to audiences. All the stuff there is to love about The Lord of the Rings  is there in the original versions, the plethora of new and extended scenes merely add to that for fans. And of those, they fall into three camps for me: 1....

A Stylish and Charmingly Reinvented David Copperfield

The Personal History, Adventures, Experience and Observation of David Copperfield the Younger of Blunderstone Rookery (Which He Never Meant to Publish on Any Account)  is the most important book Charles Dickens ever wrote. It is not the most famous or influential by any means (that would of course be A Christmas Carol ), but it is the book that is the purest expression of the authors’ style, identity, and worldview. It is his most personal work, semi-autobiographical in its story of the chronology from infancy to adulthood of a character who overcomes great loss and hardships to find a fulfilling life as a writer. To read David Copperfield  is to understand Dickens himself. Armando Iannucci knew this when he decided to make a new adaptation of the novel for a twenty-first century audience. He also knew that Dickens adaptations are ubiquitous at this point. Films are a bit rarer, but every few years a new television adaptation rears its head to keep the authors’ unique world an...