Over dinner when documentarian Lee Ye-ji
(Cho Yeo-jeong) is asked by some of her crew why she is making a movie about
the working class, she relates a very telling and not particularly self-aware
story of vacationing at a luxurious hotel in Qatar where her husband Han
Sang-woo (Zo In-sung) pointed out that nothing in the hotel would run without
workers -as though she had never before considered the concept that working
people contribute meaningfully to society. Her interest in them is thereafter
piqued, but in a largely condescending manner. She speaks somberly to a
prediction of working people “going away”, but it’s the attitude of someone who
can empathize from afar but not endeavour to understand. And it is more than a
little tone-deaf given she is seated across from one of her subjects Ahn Mi-ok
(Jeon Do-yeon), who takes it in a kind of stride but fails to fully conceal her
offence.
It is a scene like this that I think speaks
to the central focus and perhaps the meaning in the title of Lee Chang-dong’s Possible
Love. It is indeed possible for love to be formed between two sets of
people from very disparate backgrounds and immediate experiences, but it is a
difficult thing. Ye-ji and Mi-ok very much want it, Choi Ho-seok (Sul
Kyung-gu), Mi-ok’s husband isn’t so sold on the idea. It is the tension between
these two couples (Sang-woo is here too) amidst the question of that and some
very important contexts and emotions which fuels this film, a stunning drama of
colliding spheres.
The film is set in the aftermath of a
dramatic and violent strike-break, where police attacked a demonstration of
striking metalworkers on the roof of their factory, resulting in a handful of
deaths and afterwards the laying off of most of the workers as the company
entertains a sale to an American private equity firm. Ho-seok is one of these
poor former autoworkers, his depression and repressed trauma straining his
relationship with Mi-ok, who had also been a demonstrator in solidarity. The
two of them are singled out by Ye-ji after she observes one of their quarrels
and she resolves to make them the subjects of her next documentary, fast
becoming friends with Mi-ok -who is also getting to know Sang-woo, handsome and
highly wealthy; though Ho-seok is more mercurial with regards to Ye-ji’s
efforts to tell the story of the strike and its impacts on both workers and
their young son Cheol (Jeong Seop).
Lee, who was interestingly once a
government minister, is sharply critical to the role that powerful institutions
play in Korean society. His excellent 2007 film Secret Sunshine, on
which he first worked with Jeon, had a lot to say on the scale and predatory
practices of the Christian Church in South Korea; and here, as fellow Koreans
Bong Joon-ho and Park Chan-wook have done in recent years he takes an axe to
the overwhelming influence of corporate cruelty in late-stage capitalism.
Indeed, much like in No Other Choice,
the catalyst for everything that goes wrong is a Korean company selling out to
Americans at the expense of its Korean workforce, and through some flashback
and internet videos that Ye-ji researches we see the strength and conviction of
the union in standing against this. Those who survived the strike-break only to
be fired, nicknamed ‘the Dead’, are treated by the script and the camera like
they are traumatized war veterans, especially in one scene of a support group
in which Ho-seok can’t bring himself to say anything.
But as Lee depicts this he also expresses a
potent cynicism about how such an event and how such people are treated by
filmmakers like Ye-ji. Lee has interestingly never made a documentary himself,
his attitude here signaling a certain wariness of the form in scenes where
Ye-ji inserts her camera where it might be intrusive, even makes some choices
that unconsciously manipulate the information she is receiving. Much as she
might convince herself she is capturing these people as they are, their
relationship to that camera changes how they act. Certainly, Mi-ok behaves
differently, until she comes to grasp exactly what it is that Ye-ji is
capturing and a sense as to why. Ye-ji will downplay it, but the power
differential between the two couples is stark. The subtle ways that it is
communicated is one of the core strengths of the film amid the levels of
naivety from both Mi-ok and Ye-ji, who in her own way has good intentions but
is blind to her goal’s reductive facets.
She is also rather blind to the developing
sexual tension between Mi-ok and Sang-woo, a mildly flirtatious rapport that
Mi-ok engages in out of novelty and charmed disbelief -his status is as much an
attractive feature as his looks, and the movie is smart to hint towards this
power imbalance in how each takes the attraction, how much seriousness they
give it -in Mi-ok’s case perhaps more than she should, but not to the degree
that Sang-woo does. Nothing is ever said openly, even as this thread comes to a
sobering climax. But nothing needs to be said, the emotions are plain as day.
There is something so effortlessly
intuitive about Jeon’s understated performance here. She communicates an array
of complexity clearly through expression and nuanced acting cues alone -which
isn’t to say her dialogue is useless, it merely bolsters the characterization
already being set down. Mi-ok is tremendously interesting -starved for the
attention that Ye-ji and her camera puts on her, excited at the prospect of her
life being worthy enough for a documentary, but ultimately not so ignorant to
what that actually means -just as true of the interests she receives from
Sang-woo and the little tastes of a more elite lifestyle. Jeon is the premiere
presence in all her scenes, but her co-stars are just as adept, especially Sul,
whose rigidity betrays a man angry and traumatized over what he’s been through
that all comes out in a stellar way in the last act. And while one might look
at Cho’s presence as the kind of typecasting that would be expected from her
role as the similarly naïve elite matriarch of Parasite, she engenders some actual sympathy and humanity in spite
of her faults here. Certainly, she is
earnest in her desire to befriend her subjects, problematic though it is for
the purposes of her work. And Cho garners some real investment while playing
just as well the social pitfalls she runs afoul of.
The film is a slow-burn, but the time it
takes is meaningful. You are absorbed the more that comes out about the strike,
the various testimonies and commentaries on the suppression of the Korean
working class somewhat in tandem with Ye-ji, who is equal parts with Mi-ok an
audience surrogate. Yet it is Lee juxtaposing this with the more intimate lens
on the couples that elevates and complicates the nature of this story. It cuts
to fundamental differences in perception and personality informed by class and
privilege -on both ends. Offence can be unintentional, but it doesn’t exist in
a vacuum. The gradual disillusionment of Mi-ok and Ho-seok speaks to a certain
hollow chasm between the four despite the overtures of friendliness. And the
question of what the documentary really intends to do, and how just and ethical
it really is, are front and centre. It is worth noting as well that while there
is turbulence between Mi-ok and Ho-seok at times, there is understanding too; something
clearly absent to a degree in the relationship between Ye-ji and Sang-woo.
In the last act, amidst all of this -and
moments that feel genuinely earnest, such as the four dancing happily together-
there is Cheol, who never connects in any way with Ye-ji or Sang-woo, but does
forge some kind of off-screen comradery with the wealthy couple’s
groundskeeper. Was his lead what his parents should have been following? Possible Love doesn’t outright balk at
the idea of its characters bonding in an authentic way with one another -and
indeed part of what makes it so compelling is how, with the women at least,
there is real conviction there. Yet, no serendipitous full moon experience can
change that they are a world apart, and the context behind their collaboration
doesn’t seem to move that needle. The film ends in a bleak, uncertain place and
it is quite effective. It is paired though with a certainty of spiritual
righteousness, perhaps the more important thing to take heed of.
Support me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/JordanBosch
Follow me on Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/jordanbosch.bsky.social
Letterboxd: https://letterboxd.com/jbosch
Twitter: https://twitter.com/Jordan_D_Bosch

Comments
Post a Comment