Skip to main content

Why You Should Watch Star Trek: Lower Decks

Contrive enough world-building, and every major franchise will have its corners of untapped storytelling potential. And often those most curious corners are the ones that approach the grandiosity of such stories from a relatable vantage point. It can be fun to wonder about the everyday people living in the margins of superhero movies for example, especially the more extravagant universes like the MCU, which typically doesn’t care much for regular folks (outside of the occasional Spider-Man movie) and would actually be kind of a horrifying place to live the more you think about it. But also kind of a funny place, given that grounded perspective on superhero activities. The same is true of any monoculture franchise -what is it like to be a run-of-the-mill stormtrooper in Star Wars or part of a Bond villain’s army of goons, or a mere duty ensign in Star Trek possibly waiting to be killed on an away mission.
Some of these nifty concepts have made it to screen, but perhaps none more directly and legitimately than Star Trek: Lower Decks, a show that could only work several decades into an established franchise. It’s a much more recent series, airing between 2020 and 2024, and is in its own way the starkest departure for any Star Trek show to date. Virtually every other Star Trek show has its campy and comical elements -even full episodes- but definitely land more on the drama side of things than otherwise. Star Trek: Lower Decks however is a comedy show, with undercurrents of drama and serious themes now and again, but typically it plays things for laughs. That might be shocking enough on its own, but it is also an animated series -the first since the short 1973 Saturday morning follow-up to the original series- and it opines to be fully integrated into the regular world and continuity of the rest of the Star Trek universe with a consistent timeline relative to other shows and many a guest appearance and reference made.
Funny enough though, it works pretty well for this -setting itself apart in tone but epitomizing well the spirit of Star Trek almost as much as its clearest influence, Star Trek: The Next Generation. The characters may behave in a more wacky light and engage in more outrageous stories to even the weirdest bits of Star Trek up to that point, but the energy it bristles with is quite wholesome and endearing.
Of course there’s a wide gap between Lower Decks and the last series I discussed, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Obviously there have been several shows in between and even a few movies. The J.J. Abrams reboot series of movies, set in their own offshoot universe, are not as bad as their reputation -with the exception of Star Trek: Into Darkness. But they are their own thing. As for the shows, I will admit that Star Trek: Enterprise, a prequel series set before the establishment of the Federation that ran for four seasons in the early 2000s is a blind spot for me (though I do intend to watch it through eventually). And as for the two modern Star Trek shows that preceded Lower Decks, Star Trek: Discovery and Star Trek: Picard, I don’t think they are wholly worth recommending. Discovery, which is set some ten years before the original series and then starting in season three some several hundred years later, has strong and interesting moments and characters (particularly Saru played by Doug Jones and -for a time- Captain Lorca played by Jason Isaacs), but its lows are quite low and its serialized storytelling often tedious. And Picard had a fairly decent first season, with a curious premise and a compelling cast of new characters, but leaned more and more into nostalgia at the expense of storytelling in its following seasons. Much as I enjoy the reunited cast of The Next Generation, it’s not enough to recommend the series on its own terms.
However each of those shows are kind of popularly disliked, for just and unjust reasons; but one that a lot of millennial Star Trek fans have a lot of nostalgia for is Star Trek: Voyager, which aired alongside Deep Space Nine for most of its seven year run and is often grouped alongside that show and The Next Generation as part of a trifecta of classic Star Trek. And I’ll admit to a certain fondness for Voyager myself. Its pilot, “Caretaker”, might be the best of the Star Trek pilots -establishing how the starship Voyager winds up stranded in the deepest depths of the Delta Quadrant facing a decades-long journey home, alongside the crew of a rebel Maquis vessel who must be integrated into the starfleet personnel. It’s a really strong premise that unfortunately the show rarely fully lived up to. Within a few episodes, most of the ideological conflict between starfleet and Maquis is done away with, the resource issues around Voyager’s isolation are rarely brought up, same of the psychological effects on the crew, and the show winds up largely an episodic planet-of-the-week style series in the vein of The Next Generation but less ambitious. And in the latter years, its hyper-fixation on the Borg (due largely to the success of Star Trek: First Contact) make the Borg into a boring villain. The show has some good things going for it, the cast perhaps above all. Say what you will about Captain Kathryn Janeway, but Kate Mulgrew is a good domineering presence at the head of the ship. Formerly disgraced pilot Tom Paris (Robert Duncan McNeill) is a great snarky injection of life into several episodes. Tim Russ’s Tuvok, the Vulcan chief of security, comes close to Spock at times in his stoicism and deadpan attitude. Seven of Nine, a former Borg drone brought onto the show in the fourth season primarily for sex appeal, is an often intriguing outsider character owing in large part to Jeri Ryan’s performance. But the best part of the show by far is its other outsider character, the Doctor -played exceptionally by Robert Picardo- a self-aware emergency medical hologram called upon to be the ship’s physician who spends much of the series seeking greater agency for himself between a viciously sarcastic bedside manner. And the show does have an array of enjoyable elements and pretty good episodes, including “Caretaker”, “Jetrel”, “Projections”, “The Thaw”, “Tuvix”, “Future’s End”, “Real Life”, “Distant Origin”, “Year of Hell”, “Mortal Coil”, “Waking Moments”, “Message in a Bottle”, “Living Witness” (Voyager’s best episode), “One”, “Timeless”, “Blink of an Eye”, “Life Line”, and “Author, Author”.
Of course the episodic structure that made Voyager in its time a little less compelling than something like Deep Space Nine is exactly the kind of thing that Star Trek: Lower Decks adopts and is very refreshing for. Coming on the heels of Discovery and Picard, both shows that took the ‘season-length movie’ approach to their storytelling (and are both I think a little less memorable and re-watchable as a result of that), Lower Decks was designed to return to at least a vestige of this classical format. It was pitched in 2018 by Mike McMahan, a writer on Rick and Morty, as a show that would be about the low-level grunt personnel on a starfleet vessel -its basic premise and title deriving from the Next Generation episode “Lower Decks”. The show would be about a collection of ensigns in various departments and what they have to put up with during the adventures a starship would be involved in. It fits the mold of a workplace comedy in space well, but of course with McMahan and several writers and animators coming from the world of Rick and Morty it would also mean a little more deranged action and an adult sense of humour. It was a promise that many fans dreaded, not helped by an animation style that looks very much of a piece with that show. The fear was that this would be a Star Trek show designed to make fun of the Star Trek brand, that would deviate far from canon and even farther in tone; that it might be nothing more than a joke show.
What it actually is however, is a love letter to Star Trek -and like any good love letter it doesn’t brush past the flaws or the frankly ridiculous elements there are to contend with. Lower Decks loves Star Trek in its highs and lows alike and makes that clear throughout the series -perhaps the most fan-service-y of any Star Trek show, but one that pairs its fan service with its own style and consistency. Ultimately, a lot of fans have gravitated towards it for that fact. Its characters are practically fans themselves, and their energy about the whole adventurous nature of their enterprise (pun intended) is part of what makes Lower Decks the first really fun Star Trek show in a long-time. More than any other, it is perhaps not one to come into blind -it does rely at least a little on its viewers’ familiarity with the franchise. But as McMahan has stated, it is a Rosetta Stone for the franchise, connecting to various corners of the universe and providing its audience a gateway while staying true to its own priorities as well. If you’ve dipped more than a toe into this universe, Lower Decks is the next good plunge.
Certainly it is for fans of 90s Star Trek, which Lower Decks is set in the immediate vicinity of -just about a year after the events of Star Trek: Nemesis, the last of the Next Generation movies. The show takes place on the Cerritos, a Federation support ship typically tasked with lesser missions and captained by the competent yet beleaguered Carol Freeman (Dawnn Lewis). Her first officer Jack Ransom (Jerry O’Connell), is a bit of a cocky playboy. Serving as chief of security is the violet and hardened Bajoran Shaxs (Fred Tatasciore), and as ship’s doctor a frank and fussy Caitian (a cat-like species from the original animated series) called T’Ana (Gillian Vigman). These however are not the important characters of the show, they just make the decisions that effect a quartet of plucky Lower Deckers: Sam Rutherford (Eugene Cordero) -a nerdy enthusiastic engineer with several cyborg implants, D’Vana Tendi (Noel Wells) -an excitable Orion scientist with a curious history and an insatiable love for starfleet, Brad Boimler (Jack Quaid) -a neurotic pencil pusher with an encyclopedic knowledge of regulations but little practical gusto despite hefty ambitions for his career, and the show’s de-facto lead Beckett Mariner (Tawny Newsome) -an irreverent rebel and troublemaker who’s all about the fun of starfleet but not the responsibilities, and who is in fact the underachieving daughter of Captain Freeman. Most of the show’s stories and comedy come out of these four, their reactions and escapades around various Star Trek scenarios, their relationships to the senior crew and to themselves within the framework of starfleet. As the series goes along they are joined by a fifth unofficial ‘Lower Decker’ in the Vulcan T’Lyn (Gabrielle Ruiz) and are given more responsibilities and more standing amongst the Cerritos crew.
The status quo of this show and its tone does take a little getting used to. Its first few episodes especially feel very much in that hyper-energetic  smartass Rick and Morty mold, with Mariner a stand-in for the impulsive and chaotic Rick while Boimler is the awkward, hysterical Morty. The show sets itself apart from the rest of the franchise, not just in its animation but in what it gets away with through that animation. Lower Decks is in many ways a more violent Star Trek show, and at the start, almost always for comedic effect. It is at times notably more raunchy, more open in addressing the kinds of topics and taboos implied by the Star Trek universe that other shows prefer to avoid (for example, what a lot of people would realistically use the holodeck for). It is more prone to shock value, again allowed by the animated medium, in the directions certain adventures take and their occasionally comically horrifying consequences -it might take a lightly goofy premise another show had explored and go as far as possible with it. And of course it has a lot more profanity -albeit censored- yet in this also exemplifying a more frank and direct style of dialogue that in fairness was not permitted on past shows for a number of reasons beyond those shows’ controls. Yet for Lower Deckers the show has a way of making that feel appropriate. Indeed, the perspective of this show fits its style. These are the idiosyncratic underdogs who don’t get the credit on other Star Trek shows but keep each of the ships or stations functioning. The groundlings who on some fundamental level are way more accurate analogues to the fans than any Kirk or Picard or even O’Brien. It makes sense they would be a little more crude.
And these characters are in fact stand-ins for the fans. The franchise experimented with fan-insert characters before -notably Reginald Barclay (Dwight Schultz), a recurring character on both The Next Generation and Voyager. But Barclay was not written by fans, the Lower Deckers are. And as such, for as silly and tongue-in-cheek as the show frequently gets over the norms and tendencies of this franchise, the comedy of Lower Decks is never mean-spirited at the expense of Star Trek and its higher themes. The idiosyncrasies of serving in starfleet are pointed out constantly, but the overriding philosophies of both the show and the characters -who joined starfleet for a reason- are taken seriously. On occasions when they aren’t, it is often coming from Mariner -whose cynicism and wildcard attitude are painted over time as character flaws. The rest of the gang are really just a bunch of good-hearted nerds, if a little out of their depths. And nothing proves this more than their invariably fanboy reactions to situations, technologies, and especially references and guest stars, of which there are many.
Lower Decks can sometimes be a fan service show for this, to the point it caters a little bit and would be a lesser experience for non-fans, missing out on a bunch of jokes and contexts. But it largely takes care not to be just about that, as it fixates usually on the personalities of its characters, their own conflicts, and the uniqueness of the Cerritos and its crew within this universe. Still, there’s plenty of that nostalgic dopamine rush to be found. Characters from virtually every previous Star Trek series make cameos across the show, voiced by their original actors, and given space to be a bit recontextualized by the looser tone. There’s almost always a meta component -yet the Lower Deckers don’t just point to and reference the past but they comment on it in ways that  are both relevant to their own character and express just a more nuanced take with time. They’ll prod at and call out the tropes of Star Trek, but they’ll also engage with them in a critical way -without ever fully dismissing or denigrating them. For instance there are a lot of ways they could do that in say, the episode “Twovix” from season four -which is largely a tribute to Voyager- but all of the jokes at the expense of that show are underlined with love. Relishing in the ephemera of Star Trek is a favourite past-time of this series, which accepts and respects the franchise in its totality while aptly critiquing where necessary. Lower Decks knows that you can’t love a thing like Star Trek without being able to recognize its oddball eccentricities and shortcomings; things that should be addressed but don’t need to be taken away from its appeal.
While fan service may be something the show indulges in, it is also an avenue for texture. The Cerritos is probably the most diverse starship in the entire franchise -its crew notably multiracial and multi-species, more than a dozen past aliens from throughout the franchise appear as Cerritos personnel. And in some cases it goes deep. The cat-like Caitians never before appeared outside the quasi-canonical Animated Series, and yet there is one serving as chief doctor. Another of the senior officers Kayshon (Carl Tart) is a Tamarian -the race from the acclaimed Next Generation episode “Darmok” who speak in metaphor. Trills, Bolians, Tellarites, Vulcans appear across the show; an Andorian ensign called Jennifer Sh’reyan (Lauren Lapkus) serves as a rival and then girlfriend of Mariner’s -and yes, Mariner is openly bisexual, making her the first queer lead of a Star Trek show; and just in general Lower Decks features a fair degree of welcome queerness in the margins. This tapestry within the character of the crew marks the series in a very positive way -no other Star Trek show more aptly demonstrates that “infinite diversity in infinite combinations” ethos.
And it allows the show to make its own statement of world-building from these various pieces left behind by other shows. A good example are the Orions -a race dating back to the franchise’s original pilot but who were never defined beyond sex slaves and later pirates. The Orions had appeared in just nine episodes across the entire franchise before Lower Decks, yet through the character of Tendi -the first Orion in starfleet- and her relationship to her people (and her organized crime family especially) they are fleshed out here more than they have ever been, the relationship they have to and occasional prejudices from the Federation spotlighted and discussed. Likewise, the Pakleds, a one-off alien from a mediocre episode of The Next Generation meant as a one-note ‘idiot’ species, appear several times in the first few seasons, imbued with a little more character and even dignity. Same is true  of the Exocomp, a clunky robot from another little-remembered episode of The Next Generation -one dubbed ‘Peanut Hamper’ appears as a crew-member in episodes of Lower Decks; and also the ship’s resident dolphin navigators -a concept alluded to in the franchise’s past but never depicted directly. The show of course invents worlds and aliens of its own as well, such as the tusked scavenger Drookmani, the fish-faced Laaperians, and the bird-like Klowakhans -represented notably in the Cerritos’ resident therapist Doctor Migleemo (Paul F. Tompkins).
Certainly, there is a lot he has to work with on this ship, which endures its share of Star Trek-y trauma. But also a share of inner and interpersonal issues. Even for Star Trek, the character arcs on this show feel intensely about personal growth -these characters are after all closer to the beginning of their starfleet careers and have a lot of growing up to do. That includes Mariner who has been an ensign for close to a decade by the start of the show owing to her own self-sabotaging ways. Mariner's carefree cynicism about starfleet is an avenue for the show to play around, but the writers take it seriously as well, interrogating her issues with authority and her mother especially -eventually getting to the heart of challenging why she is in starfleet, what has birthed this attitude in her, and how she can find purpose and fulfillment within its bounds. From early in the show, it is clear that she is deeply principled and has a strong moral core in spite of the troublesome rule-breaker image she projects and the barriers she puts up. She genuinely believes in the mission of starfleet but cannot express it openly the way others do due to a mix of insecurity, pressure, and past trauma. All of this is addressed throughout the show as she evolves, through standout experiences and confrontations but also through her relationships to her friends and their unexpected loyalty to her -especially from Boimler. And it is a great joy of the series to watch her gradually accept her starfleet life and family, to see her go from someone totally dismissive of this world, its tropes and its mores, to actually being thrilled to be a part of it -without undergoing a total character overhaul. Newsome plays it all with a great deal of fun and genuine pride.
Boimler's long-form arc is not the reverse of hers but it sees his expectations and ambitions challenged as he comes to discover what kind of starfleet officer he is meant to be, outside of the dreams and goals he has set for himself. Discovering where his strengths and weaknesses are is a big part of this. He gets a notable test of this early on when he accepts a transfer to the Titan, the ship commanded by Captain Riker and is out of his depth against that ship's more hectic pace and action. While Mariner comes to learn the role and purpose of starfleet rules, Boimler's great lesson is on accepting when they can and must be broken, when he needs to improvise and trust his gut. As the show goes along he is allowed more chances to explore this, building up his confidence and crystallizing the leadership qualities he aspires to have. Exposure to Mariner gradually makes him less of an awkward character until he is less a comic foil for her and more a necessary contrast. Boimler and Mariner do come to ultimately bring out the best in each other, one of the franchise's great duos guided by the chemistry of Newsome and Quaid -Quaid being quite perfect in the role in all of its various facets.
Where Mariner and Boimler compliment each other via contrast, Rutherford and Tendi are just naturally complimentary. Both are starfleet nerds exhilarated by their respective disciplines -engineering and science- and both have very happy-go-lucky attitudes. The show flirts at times with the idea of feelings between them (Mariner and Boimler for the record are never entertained as non-platonic), and it is a shame that the show never has the chance to fully develop this. But their energies are quite enjoyable individually as well. Rutherford's relationship to his cyborg components and his general -sometimes overly confident- affinity for technological advances is a curious centrepiece of his character as we see its propensity just as much for harm -he loses his memories for a time early in the show. One of the darker corners of this concerns how he came by his cybernetic implants and who he was before them, revealed in the third season alongside both the physical and psychological ramifications it has left on him. It casts his tech enthusiasm in a new light as he is forced to reckon with the role of artificial intelligence impending on one's humanity -a very cogent topic for the show to address. He does a fairly good job of it by the end.
Perhaps the most thrilling arc however is Tendi's pervasive conflict through the series, revolving around her relationship to her Orion roots against her love of starfleet. It is very much in the spirit of several past Star Trek characters such as Spock, Worf, and Odo -proud members of a culture they nonetheless clash with for various reasons. Tendi doesn't suffer much discrimination herself, but she sees often the misconceptions her starfleet colleagues have towards Orions. She herself is proof of their dimensions, totally uninterested in the piracy and criminal businesses associated with Orions, but also in her bubbly attitude and people-pleaser tendencies. The contrast between her and other Orions when they appear on the show is incredibly fascinating, and the best aspects of Tendi's character come through when she has to deal with that. When she is forced to reveal the exceptional fighting skills for instance she tries to suppress around her starfleet friends. Her ideals and Orion ideals do not always intersect, and especially in the fifth season where she, for a time resigned from starfleet, is in the piracy fold we get a very blunt illustration of that. Much as she may be ashamed of her background though she does not reject it outright, and even comes to understand it as a valuable tool for her growth and self-discovery.
All of these arcs play out over a much shorter span of time than in typical Star Trek shows. Lower Decks ran five seasons, but in the modern era those seasons are sadly much reduced. There are several drawbacks to this trend in television -less time spent with the characters being a big one, and as a result even at a respectable run longer than a lot of shows nowadays get, it feels shortchanged. Looking at episode recommendations it thus leaves less to choose from, but a larger percentage of the show’s overall episodes. I might as well recommend all fifty but in lieu of that here are the particular highlights.
There are some growing pains in that first season as is typical for Star Trek. “Terminal Provocations”, in the back-half of the season is the first episode to really stand out beyond the gimmick of the workplace-comedy in the Star Trek world. That is the episode that introduces Badgey (Jack McBrayer) an evil hologram starfleet badge accidentally created by Rutherford in a good send-up of holodeck-goes-wrong episodes that truly illustrates the chaos the show is capable of. “Much Ado About Boimler” does some nifty stuff with the idea of being caught between phases of a transporter beam -something addressed in an episode of The Next Generation, but treated more curiously and amusingly as a condition here. It is also the first episode to flesh out Mariner’s complexes as she contends with a former classmate taking temporary command of the Cerritos. Her character is expanded upon further in “Crisis Point” in which she acts out some disturbing impulses with holodeck recreations of her crew as unconventional therapy, shocking her friends and revealing to herself the root of her behavioural issues. And the finale “No Small Parts” brings out the reveal of Mariner and Freeman’s connection against a backdrop of an entertaining action-heavy plot that ends in some dramatic developments for both Rutherford and Boimler and a breakthrough for Mariner and her mother.
Season two begins on a slightly new status quo, with Rutherford suffering amnesia and Boimler assigned to the Titan, and it takes a few episodes before things settle back into their groove. “Kayshon, His Eyes Open” presents a fun alternate spin on the premise of “Second Chances” from The Next Generation (appropriately in an episode where Jonathan Frakes guest stars), whilst showcasing in a silly storyline for the other characters how the absence of Boimler hurts their dynamic and Mariner especially. Later in the season once reunited, “An Embarrassment of Dooplers” provides an open reconciliation between Boimler and Mariner in a really good mellow episode that also features a great absurd alien concept. Probably the best episode of the season is “wej Duj”, which introduces a couple major supporting characters to the show in T’Lyn, a Lower Decker on a Vulcan ship and Ma’ah, a Lower Decker on a Klingon ship -both of which alongside the Cerritos come together over a crisis involving the Pakleds’ use of a devastating weapon. In addition to the glimpse at other types of ground-level officers within this world, both Ma’ah and T’Lyn are really well-defined. The last episode of the season, “First First Contact” again sees some potential role shifting as Mariner confronts long-seeded abandonment issues in the prospect of her mother taking a promotion and Rutherford discovers a dark truth behind his implants, deepening the show’s character drama in unexpected ways.
The silliness is never fully sacrificed for this though, and in season three there are some good moments of it. Such as in “The Least Dangerous Game” where Boimler in an attempt to be bold volunteers himself as prey to an alien hunter, while in her storyline Mariner clashes with Commander Ransom, now her direct supervisor, provoking her worst impulses. “Reflections” entertains the notion of a starfleet jobs fair, that Boimler and Mariner are forced to work. However it is contrasted with a storyline for Rutherford, wherein his implants manifest a darker, former version of himself. Then there is “Hear All, Trust Nothing”, the show’s Deep Space Nine tribute episode, in which the crew travel to the eponymous station, interact with Kira and Quark and foil a kidnapping plot. The episode also nicely develops Mariner via her relationship with Jennifer, and also Tendi’s feelings around her Orion heritage. And “The Stars at Night” is another good action-heavy finale that functions also as a closing-out of Mariner’s indecision about her future within starfleet, resigning temporarily before being  beckoned back to stop a mad admiral and the threat of his fleet of ships corrupted in their programming by the dark Rutherford’s code -another potent metaphor on the dangers of A.I.
Season four sees a few significant new changes to the show, such as the induction of T’Lyn into the series’ core group (if not the series core cast), and fairly early the series finally allows these characters to graduate from ensigns to lieutenants junior grade. The season begins with a tribute episode to Voyager called “Twovix” -and is is amusingly full of random ephemera from that show whilst taking its most contentious episode and playing it out to its most ridiculous extreme. It is very fun. “I Have No Bones Yet I Must Flee” is also a silly good time as Mariner and Ransom go on a rescue mission to a menagerie where a cute but horrifying bone-drinking alien is on the loose. In “Something Borrowed, Something Green” the extent of Tendi’s past training is revealed alongside the introduction of her family and a personal emotional conflict between Tendi and her sister over her choice to join starfleet. It’s some good intimate drama the show engages in here, surpassed only by Mariner’s in “The Inner Fight” which at last reveals the traumatic origin of her cynicism and self-sabotaging tendencies, linking her story rather beautifully to that of the original “Lower Decks” episode of The Next Generation. The episode also pairs her with a returning Ma’ah -an unexpected source of inspiration and his own Klingon kind of support. The season finale “Old Friends, New Planets” centres on a surprising returning legacy character and an arc slowly built through the season. Critically, it marks Mariner’s most ardent support of starfleet yet.
A sacrifice of that finale was Tendi resigning from starfleet and rejoining the family piracy as part of a deal -and that is where she is for a few episodes at the start of the show’s final season as she partakes in a skirmish with rival Blue Orions. It means she doesn’t take part in the primary events of “Dos Cerritos” which sees the ship interacting with a parallel universe version of their crew including a Captain Mariner, confident bearded Boimler, and fully-cybernetic Rutherford -each of whom reflect on their primary counterparts in interesting ways -some alluring, some repulsive. Afterwards Boimler will gradually grow a beard out over the course of the season. The episode “A Farewell to Farms” follows up once more with Ma’ah, as Mariner and Boimler become involved in a mission to restore his honour, a nice follow-up and pastiche on the great Klingon episodes of past series. One of the last great weird episodes of the show is “Starbase 80?!”, wherein the crew visit an infamously ‘cursed’ starbase and fend off what appears to be a zombie epidemic whilst finding an endearing charm in the base’s anachronisms. In the boldly named “Fully Dilated”, Mariner, Tendi, and T’Lyn spend about a year on a pre-industrial planet with a time dilation while Boimler and Rutherford desperately try to bring them back. It’s a charming pastiche that includes a great Brent Spiner appearance and a decent arc for Tendi and T’Lyn. Then there is “Fissure Quest”, the most extravagantly fan-servicey episode of the series -featuring a slew of guest appearances across four different iterations of Star Trek (and one of the more popular fan ships) while also being a very important episode for the Boimler and Mariner relationship and a winking parody of multiverse stories -as it features a clone of Boimler trying to stop a threat to the multiverse. It carries over, though with strictly the regular  cast, in the series finale “The New Next Generation” -in which Mariner, Boimler, Tendi, and Rutherford each get a shining moment in their quest to contain a rift spewing out multiverse chaos. It gets a little bit convoluted at times, but ultimately makes for a fittingly grand finale for these characters. Satisfying and even a little emotional.
Star Trek: Lower Decks deserved its sixth season, it deserved the chance to go out a little more on its own terms. Creator Mike McMahan has raised the possibility of a movie follow-up but there are no plans for it as of yet (there are no plans for future Star Trek at all in this horrendous situation at Paramount). Lower Decks may look on its surface like either a shallow comedy take on the franchise or simply fan service for its own sake, but it is actually one of the most earnest and enjoyable shows in all of Star Trek, as meaningfully character-driven as the best of them and one of the most ardent believers in the brand’s overarching philosophies -something that should not be taken for granted and again especially not now. The modern Star Trek shows have been a mixed bag and the toxicity of internet culture has really not helped them at all. A lot of it is overblown and reactionary. Discovery, Picard, and especially Strange New Worlds have their moments and enjoyable material and characters (I have not yet seen Prodigy or Starfleet Academy though I am sure the same is true of those), but Lower Decks is the only one I can holistically recommend. It plays to the fans sure, but it is fun and intrepid in its own way -its characters though more offbeat are wonderful additions to the Star Trek universe and it represents both with love and irony everything that Star Trek ought to be.
Star Trek is adrift for the moment, possibly due to the chaos going on at Paramount and the series’s basic ideology being so far from that of its new corporate masters. There are a couple seasons already produced of Strange New Worlds and Starfleet Academy that have yet to air, but nothing in the pipe. I am concerned what the next iteration of Star Trek -which is too pronounced a brand for Paramount to dispose of- will be. What it should be is something a little more like Lower Decks in its outlook, or like Deep Space Nine in its thematic boldness, or like The Next Generation in its boundless curiosity, or like the original Star Trek in its hopeful vision. Each built out a captivating image of the future worth striving towards, worth embracing. Star Trek still has an abundance of things to say and to teach, new spaces to explore. I would like to see it get that chance. And if you have seen these shows, been entertained by them and taken away their critical messages and meanings, I’m sure you likewise would wish that Star Trek and its convictions live long and prosper.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Strange History of the American Spoof Movie

Parody movies have been around for a lot longer than we tend to think of them. Even from the earliest days of Hollywood there were movies meant to satirize a particular subject or genre. In the silent era, Buster Keaton was responsible for a few. And in the early sound era, almost as soon as the monster pictures took off did you see comic versions of them -Abbott and Costello hosting a few. But parody movies tended to be subtle for most of cinema history, or parody came in conjunction with another goal of the comedy. It really wasn’t until the 1980s and 90s that it took off and became popularly understood. And there is perhaps a line to be drawn to the counterculture comedy explosion that began in the 1970s through avenues like  Saturday Night Live , which frequently parodied from even its earliest years popular movies and cultural properties of the time. But that is still a way’s back. To my generation though, ‘parody movie’ is perhaps a less known term than the more blunt ‘s...

Notes on the Title Cards of The Lord of the Rings

It might be sacrilege for one who both considers The Lord of the Rings  trilogy to be one of the greatest triumphs of cinema and has been an avid lover of the films since adolescence, to declare that the original theatrical cuts of the films are better than the much beloved extended editions. Easily it’s my most controversial opinion regarding these movies. Don’t get me wrong, I do like the extended editions quite a lot, especially as someone who just enjoys spending time in that universe. They flesh it out more, add extra flavour, and in increasing the length by about an hour really emphasize the epic quality of these films. But I find that the original cuts are generally more cleanly paced, more seamlessly edited, and much more accessible to audiences. All the stuff there is to love about The Lord of the Rings  is there in the original versions, the plethora of new and extended scenes merely add to that for fans. And of those, they fall into three camps for me: 1....

A Stylish and Charmingly Reinvented David Copperfield

The Personal History, Adventures, Experience and Observation of David Copperfield the Younger of Blunderstone Rookery (Which He Never Meant to Publish on Any Account)  is the most important book Charles Dickens ever wrote. It is not the most famous or influential by any means (that would of course be A Christmas Carol ), but it is the book that is the purest expression of the authors’ style, identity, and worldview. It is his most personal work, semi-autobiographical in its story of the chronology from infancy to adulthood of a character who overcomes great loss and hardships to find a fulfilling life as a writer. To read David Copperfield  is to understand Dickens himself. Armando Iannucci knew this when he decided to make a new adaptation of the novel for a twenty-first century audience. He also knew that Dickens adaptations are ubiquitous at this point. Films are a bit rarer, but every few years a new television adaptation rears its head to keep the authors’ unique world an...