Skip to main content

Schrader Transcends and Provokes with Profound Character Study


Paul Schrader is a figure really only known in cinephile circles. In addition to having written a number of great movies of the 1970s and 80s including Martin Scorsese’s Taxi DriverRaging Bull, and The Last Temptation of Christ, and being an accomplished director in his own right (Hardcore, American Gigolo, Affliction), he’s also written extensively on film criticism and theory. His popular essay, Notes on Noir, was even required reading in one of my Film History classes. He’s a man who knows his medium incredibly well, and it’s perhaps for that reason why First Reformed is one of the most thoughtful films I’ve seen come out in recent years. Every scene is presented knowing it will be analyzed, every action and beat carefully constructed. It’s a slow film, but there’s method to every minute of it.
A former military chaplain, Reverend Ernst Toller (Ethan Hawke) is the pastor of First Reformed Church, a historical chapel in upstate New York, with troubled physical and mental health issues. As he commits to writing a journal for a year, he tends to Mary (Amanda Seyfried), a pregnant woman whose husband Michael (Philip Ettinger) is a despairing radical environmentalist. Still shaken by the death of his son in Iraq, combined with a growing disillusionment with the world and a crisis of faith, Toller attempts to find purpose and hope through despondent circumstances.
This film feels like it was made by one of the masters, clearly taking direct influence from great art-house cinema. It belongs to the Transcendental Style Schrader coined in his book of the same name, characterized by slow pacing and insubstantial editing, common to the films of (as focussed on in the book) directors like Carl Theodor Dreyer, Yasujiro Ozu, and Robert Bresson. And indeed there are many moments in First Reformed that feel like an Ozu film with lingering unmoving shots, or a Dreyer film with empty spaces, particularly in Toller’s manse, to reflect the emptiness felt by the main character. It draws you into the world, banalities and all, allows you to contemplate and more closely feel the characters, so that when it’s departed from for something more conventional, it stands in much starker contrast, and thus is more effective. And there are a number of times both visually and narratively where First Reformed does that.
Schrader is an expert at writing characters in conflict with themselves -he gave us Travis Bickle after all; and Reverend Toller is no exception, superbly played with depth and desolation by Ethan Hawke. This is a character with frustrations, doubt, regret, desperation, and some resentment, that all has to be cloaked in a façade of sure spiritedness. Throughout the film he goes back and forth between actions predicating redemption and downfall -Schrader has an interest in self-destructive characters after all. And Hawke goes above and beyond with this demanding role, exercising passion and uncertainty through his thoughts, while remaining subtle in person. You’re constantly intrigued by Toller, worried for him as well, but also frightened of him, and the root of these feelings are etched in the very manner of his character. Ethan Hawke proves once again that with excellent writing, he’s one of the greatest working film actors. It’s his best performance since Boyhood, and one of his career highlights overall. Amanda Seyfried is very good as Toller’s tether, the one person who seems to need him and rely on the faith he administers. She and him forge a real connection that’s essential to the movie. Cedric Kyles (a.k.a. Cedric the Entertainer) also appears as the pastor of the megachurch that owns First Reformed’s landmark, drawing an important contrast between two very different means of Christian fellowship.
This is definitely a movie directed by a screenwriter, as it’s extensively wordy and probably overuses its voice-over narration device. Nevertheless, this can’t be said to get in the way of the movies’ value as a visual story, not just for the aforementioned style, but for some great imagery, beautiful shots, and one sequence that’s unexpectedly visually experimental and transporting. However the power of the film still lies in the written word and what Schrader is trying to convey. The story itself has noticeably a lot in common with Taxi Driver, including that films’ pessimistic outlook and the protagonists’ uncompromising desire to do something about a perceived great wrong in their world. But the two are cousins only, First Reformed being purely Schrader. It would be perhaps presumptuous to assume Schrader, who was brought up Calvinist, is working through his own faith-based conundrums, but the movies’ religious leanings are no accident. There’s a statement being made, a challenge being posed regarding faith and the world today. It’s also worth considering the allegorical reading that comes with a film featuring a pregnant character called Mary, and a significant off-screen character called Joseph.
I don’t dare spoil the ending, but it’s puzzling, deeply fascinating, and lastingly impressionable. It’s likely influenced by the contentious ending to Dreyer’s Ordet, but in my opinion, this one’s better. And it’s the perfect way to top off a movie that you’ll be thinking about days after seeing it. Paul Schrader didn’t make this an easy film -general audiences aren’t going to gravitate towards it at all- but he did make an immensely provocative, intense yet subdued character study and meditation on world anxieties built on richly crafted techniques and admirable influences. First Reformed may not reach a large audience, it most likely won’t be remembered come Awards season; but everyone who does see it, whether they appreciate its artistry or think it’s ostentatious, won’t soon forget it.

Follow me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/Jordan_D_Bosch 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Disney's Mulan, Cultural Appropriation, and Exploitation

I’m late on this one I know. I wasn’t willing to spend thirty bucks back in September for a movie experience I knew was going to be far poorer than if I had paid half that at a theatre. So I waited for it to hit streaming for free to give it a shot. In the meantime I heard that it wasn’t very good, but I remained determined not to skip it entirely, partly out of sympathy for director Niki Caro and partly out of morbid curiosity. Disney’s live-action Mulan  I was actually mildly looking forward to early in the year in spite of my well-documented distaste for this series of creative dead zones by the most powerful media conglomerate on earth. Mulan  was never one of Disney’s classics, a movie extremely of its time in its “girl power” gender politics and with a decidedly American take on ancient Chinese mythology. It got by on a couple good songs and a strong lead, but it was a movie that could be improved upon, and this new version looked like it had the potential to do that, emphasizing

The Hays Code was Bad, Sex in Movies is Good

Don't Look Now (1973) Will Hays, Who Knows About Sex In 1930, former Republican politician and chair of the Motion Picture Association of America Will Hayes introduced a series of self-censorship guidelines for the movie industry in response to a mixture of celebrity scandals and lobbying from the Catholic Church against various ‘immoralities’ creating a perception of Hollywood as corrupt and indecent. The Hays Code, or the Motion Picture Production Code, was formally adopted in 1930, though not stringently enforced until 1934 under the auspices of Joseph Breen. It laid out a careful list of what was and wasn’t acceptable for a film expecting major distribution. It stipulated rules against profanity, the depiction of miscegenation, and offensive portrayals of the clergy, but a lot of it was based around sexual content: “sexual perversion” of any kind was disallowed, as were any opaquely textual or visual allusions to reproduction, and right near the top “No licentious or suggestiv

Pixar Sundays: The Incredibles (2004)

          Brad Bird was already a master by the time he came to Pixar. Not only did he hone his craft as an early director on The Simpsons , but he directed a little animated film for Warner Bros. in 1999, that though not a box office success was loved by critics and quickly grew a cult following. The Iron Giant is now among many people’s favourite animated movies. Likewise, Bird’s feature debut at Pixar, The Incredibles , his own variation of a superhero movie, is often considered one of the studio’s best. And for very good reason, as the most talented director at Pixar shows.            Superheroes were once the world’s greatest crime-fighting force until several lawsuits for collateral damage (and in the case of Mr. Incredible, a hilarious suicide prevention), outlawed their vigilantism. Fifteen years later Mr. Incredible, now living as Bob Parr, has a family with his wife Helen, the former Elastigirl. But Bob, in a combination of mid-life crisis and nostalgia for the old day